Divergences in the interpretation of the Fregean conception of Bedeutung

The concept of Bedeutung is a central concept in Frege’s philosophy, however there is a huge divergence in the literature about its adequate interpretation. Dummett, Sluga, Carl, Burge, Tugendhat, and others Frege’s commentators will present discordant interpretations of Bedeutung, which are commite...

ver descrição completa

Na minha lista:
Detalhes bibliográficos
Autor principal: Giarolo, Kariel Antonio
Formato: Online
Idioma:por
Publicado em: EDUFRN
Endereço do item:https://periodicos.ufrn.br/principios/article/view/27907
Tags: Adicionar Tag
Sem tags, seja o primeiro a adicionar uma tag!
id oai:periodicos.ufrn.br:article-27907
record_format ojs
spelling oai:periodicos.ufrn.br:article-279072022-08-04T23:01:51Z Divergences in the interpretation of the Fregean conception of Bedeutung As divergências na interpretação da concepção fregeana de Bedeutung Giarolo, Kariel Antonio Bedeutung; Frege; Referência; Sentido; Significância Bedeutung Frege Reference Meaning Significance The concept of Bedeutung is a central concept in Frege’s philosophy, however there is a huge divergence in the literature about its adequate interpretation. Dummett, Sluga, Carl, Burge, Tugendhat, and others Frege’s commentators will present discordant interpretations of Bedeutung, which are commited to general aspects of Frege’s logical/philosophical perspectives. Based on this, the main goal of this paper is to reconstruct the discussions associated to the interpretation and translation of the Fregean concept of Bedeutung, showing that the tradicional characterization of Bedeutung as reference brings a series of exegetical problems. On the one hand, Bedeutung, understood as reference, implies that sentences must be understood as a special kind of proper name, however, such an interpretation seems to be incompatible with the so-called Fregean contexto principle. On the other hand, revisionista interpretations, in turn, contradict Frege’s supposed realism, besides not being compatible with the presentation found in Über Sinn umd Bedeutung. O conceito de Bedeutung é central na filosofia de Frege, entretanto existe uma grande divergência na literatura sobre sua adequada interpretação. Dummet, Sluga, Carl, Burge, Tugendhat e outros comentadores de Frege irão apresentar discordantes interpretações acerca de Bedeutung, as quais se comprometem com aspectos gerais das perspectivas lógico/filosóficas fregeanas. Com base nisso, o objetivo principal do presente artigo é reconstruir a discussão relacionada a interpretação e tradução do conceito fregeano de Bedeutung, visando mostrar que a tradicional caracterização de Bedeutung como referência traz uma série de problemas exegéticos. Por um lado, Bedeutung, entendida enquanto referência, implica que sentenças devam ser compreendidas como tipos especiais de nomes próprios, porém, tal interpretação parece ser incompatível com o chamado princípio de contexto fregeano. Por outro lado, interpretações revisionistas, por sua vez, contravém o suposto realismo de Frege, além de não serem compatíveis com a apresentação encontrada em Über Sinn und Bedeutung. EDUFRN 2022-08-04 info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion application/pdf https://periodicos.ufrn.br/principios/article/view/27907 Princípios: Revista de Filosofia (UFRN); v. 29 n. 59 (2022): Princípios: Revista de Filosofia (UFRN); 21-47 1983-2109 0104-8694 10.21680/1983-2109.2022v29n59 por https://periodicos.ufrn.br/principios/article/view/27907/15986 Copyright (c) 2022 Kariel Antonio Giarolo http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0
institution Periódicos UFRN
collection Portal de Pediódicos Eletrônicos da UFRN
language por
format Online
author Giarolo, Kariel Antonio
spellingShingle Giarolo, Kariel Antonio
Divergences in the interpretation of the Fregean conception of Bedeutung
author_facet Giarolo, Kariel Antonio
author_sort Giarolo, Kariel Antonio
title Divergences in the interpretation of the Fregean conception of Bedeutung
title_short Divergences in the interpretation of the Fregean conception of Bedeutung
title_full Divergences in the interpretation of the Fregean conception of Bedeutung
title_fullStr Divergences in the interpretation of the Fregean conception of Bedeutung
title_full_unstemmed Divergences in the interpretation of the Fregean conception of Bedeutung
title_sort divergences in the interpretation of the fregean conception of bedeutung
description The concept of Bedeutung is a central concept in Frege’s philosophy, however there is a huge divergence in the literature about its adequate interpretation. Dummett, Sluga, Carl, Burge, Tugendhat, and others Frege’s commentators will present discordant interpretations of Bedeutung, which are commited to general aspects of Frege’s logical/philosophical perspectives. Based on this, the main goal of this paper is to reconstruct the discussions associated to the interpretation and translation of the Fregean concept of Bedeutung, showing that the tradicional characterization of Bedeutung as reference brings a series of exegetical problems. On the one hand, Bedeutung, understood as reference, implies that sentences must be understood as a special kind of proper name, however, such an interpretation seems to be incompatible with the so-called Fregean contexto principle. On the other hand, revisionista interpretations, in turn, contradict Frege’s supposed realism, besides not being compatible with the presentation found in Über Sinn umd Bedeutung.
publisher EDUFRN
publishDate 2022
url https://periodicos.ufrn.br/principios/article/view/27907
work_keys_str_mv AT giarolokarielantonio divergencesintheinterpretationofthefregeanconceptionofbedeutung
AT giarolokarielantonio asdivergenciasnainterpretacaodaconcepcaofregeanadebedeutung
_version_ 1766681884917497856

Registros relacionados